He chased her to a train station.
Christine was leaving the Opera, leaving Paris,
leaving her career, to marry that idiot vicomte and go across the Channel to live in London. And she hadn’t even deigned to tell him the news herself; she’d left him a letter and he’d been blindsided by it. All the things he’d never noticed or tried not to notice: the way she looked at him, the way she smiled, the way she’d been there every day of his recovery, the way she’d long ago ceased to be a mere student... And there it was, plainly written on a sheet of paper in her small, neat handwriting.
She loved him—-
him-—but she had chosen to accept the vicomte’s proposal of marriage because she knew he would never return her feelings.
It was like having the air sucked out of his lungs, or being hit by a falling backdrop in Carlotta’s stead. In one instant of searing clarity he knew what he’d been refusing to acknowledge for months: he’d fallen in love with his student. And she was leaving to marry another man, believing he didn’t love her, when in fact he’d long ago forgotten what it was like to live without her.
He’d caught her at the station before her train arrived. He didn’t really know what he’d gone to do, or say. The truth was he didn’t know
what to say. He’d never loved anyone before, and he was having a hard time admitting to himself that he was in love, much less to the object of his affections, even though he knew she felt the same for him. They ended up having a fight. Reyer confronted her with the letter, and told her he refused to act like the lovesick imbeciles he saw fawning over the singers and dancers every performance night; it simply wasn’t his way. Christine argued that she didn’t want him to behave that way; she’d only ever wanted him the way he was. He found he couldn’t say the words she wanted to hear, couldn’t tell her he did love her—-he could only keep repeating that he didn’t want her to leave for the sake of the Opera.
And then her train had arrived, and she’d kissed him on the cheek and said goodbye with tears in her eyes, and left him there on the platform. His own eyes were dry, but the sudden emptiness in his heart did his weeping for him.
He’d chased Christine to the train station out of love, but even then, he hadn’t been able to say three simple words.